Ecumenism

To the meeting at Wimbledon of the Southwark ecumenical commission of which I am still vice-chair! Parish unity contacts were invited and there 4 of us from Croydon deanery. We saw an excellent DVD of 40 years of Catholic involvement in ecumenism which was inspiring and useful. Lots of men in funny hats giving the kiss of peace! Still we have come a long way but how one longs for true intercommunion!

Comments

Anonymous said…
Hey John, what do you mean by intercommunion?
12 May 2007 at 23:33
John the organist said…
At nearly every ecumenical encounter the desire is expressed for a sharing of the Eucharist. Catholics need to realise tha pain we give and we must all pray for the coming of the day when we will truly be One. There is so much that unites us already. We will be in for some surprises when we reach the heavenly gates!
15 May 2007 at 23:28
Anonymous said…
John, thank you for taking the time to reply to my question. I hope you don't mind if I reply a little too...

I'm still not too sure as to what you mean, you seem to be beating around the bush somewhat if you don't mind me saying.

The basic issue is that non-Catholics may not recieve Holy Communion. And I would be extremely upset if one were to do so under normal circumstances.

This is the consistent teaching of Holy Mother Church. And Holy Mother Church is incapable of decieving us that this is the correct thing to do.

As for Catholics recieving Anglican so called "Eucharist", since Anglican orders are "null and void", there isn't actually transubstantiation taking place during an Anglican service. Thus it is not the Eucharist.

There are many possibilities for fruitful and generous ecumenism, such as praying together. Recently I prayed the Rosary with an AngloCatholic. Since then he has decided to convert to Catholicism.

False ecumenism however, drives me and many of my generation, potty as it undermines the Church's teaching.
18 May 2007 at 22:04
John the organist said…
I think we should be extremely careful about discerning Christ in communion services. We can so easily give offence. Do you go to a meal and refuse to eat the food?
19 May 2007 at 07:37
Anonymous said…
Fortunately it is not "we" that have to discern that, as the Church in her wisdom has done it for us in such documents as Dominus Iesus etc.

I don't get at all offended if people don't go to recieve Communion. Indeed I often don't feel worthy to recieve communion and make a spiritual communion instead. It doesn't for a single moment offend me.

Anyway the Mass is more than a meal about "me", how about offending God?
19 May 2007 at 13:04
John the organist said…
You don't get offended! Lots of other people do! Have a look round at Mass and note how many people do not go to communion for various reasons. Pray for them! Then start praying for our fellow Christians who have faith in the Eucharist. I even know of a Baptist who believes in transsubstantiation! What is the Catholc church's aim? To get everyone to become Catholics? Read "Ut unim sint"!
19 May 2007 at 16:43
John the organist said…
When I became a Catholic the priest who prepared me that all that had gone before was so important for my spiritual journey, especially the communion I had experienced. And all that has come after that day is important too!
20 May 2007 at 15:08
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Gibraltar

18.9.17 From Seville to Gibraltar. Quicker to walk over border waving passport. Small buses drove across aiprot runway. Europe point with view to Africa. St Michael's cave and macaques. Crowded Main Street from cruise liners. RC and Anglican cathedrals and the excellent Gibraltar museum. Ice cream. People were disappointed. To Torremelinos and big hotel balcony and beach view. Went to excellent restaurant on beach and had anchovies, prawn and avocado salad and swordfish. Much cheaper than the tour extra outing which would have cost 110E. 
Read more

Easter Day

 To All  Saints Shirley arrived 9am got in at 9.30 a.m. Went OK and got a clap. Peruvian Gloria is normally unaccompanied in verse 2 Yvonne went up a tone or half a tone so I stopped trying to accompany. I'm not that clever!  Sadly this church will become a chapel of ease. I played Mascagni Easter hymn, Bach Christ lag, Alan Gray Easter hymn and Hallelujah chorus at the end. The organ is a 2 manual Bishop. This was also Revd Yvonne Clarke’s last service there. How disappointing that only 2 hymns were sung from St George’s cathedral on Songs of Praise and Praise to the holiest is NOT an Easter hymn! The Serbian choir were terrific! Very impressed by St Mary Redcliffe great singing especially the Neil Cox setting and the Jonathan Dove. Joe Cryan and Clare Alsop were not mentioned in the credits and should have been! Unimpressed by Canterbury cathedral radio broadcast. Lovely evensong at SJ Stanford in C and Te Deum in B flat. Ledger This joyful Eastertide. Antiques roadshow...
Read more